cover article

The bigger challenge in soil health is understanding how practices perform under real farming conditions, what farmers need to adopt them, and which barriers can stand in the way.

These questions were at the heart of the SoilCommunity webinar #11, “Soil Health in Practice: What Works in the Field?”, held on 15 October 2026.

Moderated by Andrés Rodríguez Seijo from the University of Vigo, the webinar brought together three complementary perspectives from farmers, researchers, and practitioners. The discussion explored regenerative grazing in the Spanish Dehesa, strategies to increase soil organic carbon in rainfed agriculture, and the practical challenges farmers face when adopting new technologies and management approaches.

Rotational Grazing in the Spanish Dehesa: Practical Lessons for Soil Health and Biodiversity

Begoña Lozano Diéguez, Fundación Global Nature / InBestSoil

Begoña Lozano Diéguez shared the experience of Dehesa El Baldío, a 232-hectare demonstration and learning farm in Extremadura, Spain.

The Dehesa is a Mediterranean agro-silvo-pastoral ecosystem where agriculture, forestry, and livestock coexist. At El Baldío, poor, degraded soils, seasonal rainfall, and long summer droughts create challenging conditions for farming and ecosystem management. The farm also works with endangered local livestock breeds, including the Blanca Cacereña cow and Merina Negra sheep.

For many years, the farm kept livestock numbers very low because grazing animals were seen as part of the degradation problem. A change came around 2015, when the farm began exploring holistic management and regenerative grazing. The experience shifted the focus from the number of animals to how livestock are managed, with grazing increasingly seen as a potential tool for ecosystem restoration.

Two practices were particularly highlighted.

  • Rotational grazing involves dividing the farm into smaller paddocks and moving cattle between them, giving vegetation sufficient time to recover. The farm initially used electric fencing and later introduced virtual fencing collars to support grazing management.
  • The second practice, redileo, builds on a traditional system in which sheep are kept overnight in a small mobile enclosure. Farmers then move the animals to a different area, giving the previously grazed area a long recovery period. According to the speaker, treated areas showed greater soil porosity, increased grass cover, improved pasture quality, and the appearance of plant species not previously observed there.

Monitoring on the farm also shows differences between grazing systems. Soil biological quality indicators were higher under rotational grazing than under conventional grazing, while plant richness and abundance were also higher in several comparisons. Soil microbial diversity was higher across bacterial, fungal, and protist communities, with particularly noticeable differences for fungi.

But Begoña also stressed that regenerative management is not an instant solution. Results can take years; there is no universal recipe, and profitability remains essential if a farming system is to survive. Limited access to knowledge, administrative requirements, rural depopulation, and the lack of support networks were among the challenges encountered along the way.

One response has been creating a Living Lab through InBestSoil, bringing researchers, farmers, cooperatives, businesses, and other stakeholders together to exchange experiences and address challenges collaboratively.

Soil Organic Carbon: Management Strategies for a More Sustainable Agriculture

Raúl San Juan Heras, LILAS4SOILS / IBERSOILL

Raúl San Juan Heras brought both a farmer’s and researcher’s perspective to the discussion.

On his 150-hectare rainfed farm in central Spain, conventional management had historically relied on mouldboard plowing every one or two years. Farmers often left fields bare for several months before sowing sunflowers, increasing their exposure to erosion during periods of heavy rainfall. At the same time, declining livestock numbers meant less organic matter was returned to agricultural soils.

Raúl gradually changed the system rather than shifting everything at once.

He replaced mouldboard plowing with a chisel plow, introduced no-till for some crops, expanded crop rotations, and began experimenting with cover crops during periods when soils would otherwise remain bare. After several years of reduced tillage, some fields have now moved completely to no-till.

The comparison between neighboring fields illustrated why long-term management matters.

In a hot, dry season, one field that had been managed with reduced tillage and more diverse rotations since 2017 produced an average sunflower yield of around 0.7 tonnes per hectare, compared with 0.2 tonnes per hectare in a neighboring field that had only recently entered the new management system. In a later season, mean yields were around 2.1 tonnes per hectare compared with 1.3 tonnes per hectare. Soil organic matter was 0.81% in the longer-managed field, compared with 0.5% in the second field.

As part of his PhD research, Raúl is also comparing conventional mouldboard plowing with cover-crop systems, including treatments where cattle graze cover crops. Although the research is still being analyzed, researchers have already observed statistically significant differences in soil organic carbon and biological activity after 18 months.

His experience also reinforced an issue that emerged repeatedly during the discussion: crop and livestock systems can complement each other. Grazing can return organic matter and nutrients to the soil, but rebuilding these connections is difficult as livestock farming and agricultural labor disappear.

From Promising Innovation to Farm Reality: Barriers to Adopting New Agricultural Practices

Felipe Cortines, Rainfed farmer

Felipe Cortines shifted the discussion from what technology promises to what happens when a farmer actually tries to use it.

Drawing on his experience on a rainfed family farm in southwestern Spain, Felipe shared two examples involving drones and variable-rate applications.

In theory, drones offered an attractive solution for identifying and treating isolated weed patches without driving machinery through a growing crop. In practice, the first barriers were regulatory. Felipe explained that his farm is near an airport and an aerodrome, which restricts drone flights, and that aerial application products are also subject to strict legal limitations. The potential financial benefit therefore had to be weighed against regulatory risk and possible penalties.

Variable-rate technology presented a different problem: access to useful data.

Developing meaningful prescriptions requires reliable information, including yield maps, soil maps, and vegetation data. But simply obtaining usable yield files proved difficult. Some maps were provided only as PDFs, others had to be manually downloaded from machinery, and some files were even stored under the wrong farmer’s name.

Even after collecting the data, another question remained: what should a farmer actually do with it?

Felipe pointed to the lack of consensus around prescriptions. Should a low-yielding area receive more seed and fertiliser, or less? The technology may operate at centimetre-level precision, but the agronomic information available to inform decisions can still be much less detailed.

The challenge is therefore not simply buying new equipment. Farmers may need training, software knowledge, licences, time to process data, and technical support. According to Felipe, service providers also need to improve their ability to offer complete, practical support that responds to farmers’ actual needs.

Post-Webinar Reflections

Although the three speakers focused on different farming contexts, several common lessons emerged from the discussion:

  • Soil health practices need to be adapted to local conditions. Climate, soil type, farming system, labour availability, and farm economics all influence what works in practice.
  • Change takes time. Improvements in soil health may only become visible after years of consistent management, requiring patience, continuity, and a willingness to adapt along the way.
  • Livestock can play an important role in soil restoration. The examples from both grazing and arable systems highlighted the value of reconnecting crop and livestock production, while also showing the challenges created by labour shortages and the decline of livestock farming.
  • Technology alone does not solve adoption barriers. Digital tools can offer new opportunities, but regulation, data quality, costs, technical support, and farmers’ capacity to use them determine whether they are practical in real farming conditions.
  • Soil health needs to make sense both environmentally and economically. Farmers are often asked to invest, take risks, and wait for results. Supporting long-term adoption therefore requires practical knowledge, peer learning, appropriate incentives, advisory support, and policies that reflect farming realities.
  • Farmer experience and scientific evidence need to work together. Understanding what works in the field also means understanding why some solutions succeed, why others struggle, and what farmers need to make lasting change possible.

If you missed the session, you can watch the full recording on the Soil Community event page.

Kommentar hinzufügen

nach oben